Face to Face with Genocide in Cambodia

Tuol Sleng Prison Museum and Choeung Ek Killing Field, Phnom Penh
15 Comments

Our introduction to Cambodia was stark. “I heard gun shots every day of my life until I turned 26,” said Choun Siluch, our guide to the temples of Angkor. He was talking about his youth during the reign of the murderous Khmer Rouge. With sadness, Choun told us that his father was the only one of four brothers, all accomplished professionals, to survive the killing that wiped out a quarter of Cambodia’s population between 1975 and 1979.

Angkor Watt guide Choun Siluch in 2005

Cambodian guide Choun Siluch at the Angkor temple complex in 2005 said he heard gunfire every day until he was 26.

We felt a pall over the beautiful country, a sense of shared trauma, embarrassment and even shame, as we toured the legendary temples and learned about the glories of the ancient Khmer kingdom.

Billboard outside the Angkor Watt complex in Siem Reap, Cambodia, saying We No Longer Need Weapons 2005

In 2005, a billboard in Siem Reap reiterates the message: “We No Longer Need Weapons.” The Cambodian civil war lasted into the 1990s.

It was 2005, just ten years after the country undertook a painful reconciliation process. Khmer Rouge leaders would not be put on trial for another year. On that trip, we chose not to go to Phnom Penh. I was afraid to see the Choeung Ek killing field or the S-21 Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum. Of course I had seen news reports about Pol Pot’s brutal war and had heard about the thousands of skulls left behind. But I was not ready to face that horror.

In October 2023, when my husband David and I returned to tour Vietnam and Cambodia’s Siem Reap with photographer Catherine Karnow, we decided that it was time to add Phnom Penh to our personal itinerary. Although we remembered the old headlines, we were ready to learn more about the 50-year-old atrocities. We were also curious to learn how the country had changed.

A bit of history  …  just for perspective

The chaos of those years was not entirely home grown. Geopolitical forces played out in the fields and forests of Cambodia like it was a playground. In the background were the French, the colonial power behind Indochina (Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos) before and following World War II. The postwar rivalry between the Soviets and the Chinese Communists was also a factor, not to mention Vietnam with its own revolutionary war raging next door.

Map of Cambodia

Cambodia is bordered by Thailand, Laos and Vietnam.

After Cambodia gained independence in 1953, it soon fell into civil war as factions battled factions. King Norodom Sihanouk, a shape-shifting opportunist, “ruled” at various times as a figurehead under the French, a one-party dictator, a supporter of the Khmer Rouge and, after fleeing to China and North Korea, the leader of the Cambodian government in exile. When the war in Vietnam spilled over the border, the United States came calling, bombing the Viet Cong who were hiding in Cambodia’s forests. That’s when the Khmer Rouge saw its chance to topple the US-backed Lon Nol government and Pol Pot took over.

Pol Pot and his cronies, Maoist-style communists influenced by the Chinese Cultural Revolution, declared 1975 to be “Year Zero.” Their goal was to transform Cambodia into a classless rural society with no poor people and no rich people. City-dwellers were force-marched into the countryside to become agricultural workers. Schools were shut, money abolished, shops closed, religion restricted and gatherings forbidden. You get the idea.

It was a difficult time for anyone to know whom to trust. Your best friend, your wife or your child could be your informer. Evil and suspicion spread over this ancient kingdom the way sticky peanut sauce clings to a piece of chicken satay. It oozed into every crevice of life. No one was immune: teachers, people wearing glasses, doctors, lawyers, engineers, military officers and city folks were all suspect.

Children as young as ten were recruited to be soldiers. One of those children was Nhem En.

The enigma of Nhem En

Catherine Karnow introduced us to Nhem En in Siem Reap as part of her Vietnam/Cambodia photo workshop. It was an encounter unlike any other I’ve experienced.

Profile portrait in dim light of Nhem En, photographer at S-21 prison, at his home in Siem Reap, Cambodia, 2023

Nhem En photographed prisoners at Tuol Sleng Prison, also known as S-21, from 1976-1979.

To prep us for the visit, Catherine gave us each the slim paperback: “Nhem En: the Khmer Rouge’s Photographer at S-21.” A sticker on the book reads: “Death Camera Operated in Toul Sleng (S-21).” The cover shows images of the people Nhem En photographed at the notorious prison before they were taken away to be tortured and executed.

That’s the short version. The longer tale recounts his selection as a child soldier and his years as photographer for the regime. The story is full of matter-of-fact details told like a legal confession, without much emotion. It was written in 2014, two years before his testimony at the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia. By the time we met him in 2023, Nhem En had told his story many times over—during legal proceedings, to newspapers including The New York Times and to groups like ours, both Cambodian and international.

Our group of eight shuffled around nervously before we set out by tuktuk to visit Nhem En at his home in Siem Reap. None of us had ever been face to face with someone who had participated in a genocide before, and our discomfort showed.

The day was humid. My camera lens fogged as we were ushered inside Nhem En’s receiving room. We were invited to sit around a large conference table. The walls, covered  with maps of Cambodia and life-size prints of people he photographed at Toul Sleng, were a bulletin board of his former life. A banner over the door said, “Welcome national and international guests,” although I didn’t notice it until we left.

Wall in the home of Nhem En, former Tuol Sleng prison photographer, in Siem Reap, Cambodia, 2023

Nhem En’s walls served as a resume of his time working for the Khmer Rouge.

Cameras clicked and questions flowed. When did you leave home as a child? Tell me about the first time you picked up a camera. What does a photograph mean to you? Would you be willing to share a moment when you were most afraid? Do you ever feel complicit in the regime?

Three women in front of a map of Cambodia at the home of Nhem En, photographer at S-21 prison, at his home in Siem Reap, Cambodia, 2023

Photographer Catherine Karnow, Ngan Do and Aisling O’Callaghan listen to Nhem En as part of Catherine’s Vietnam/Cambodia Photo Workshop in 2023.

Nhem En lost his mother at age two, and his father was an early supporter of the Khmer Rouge. After Lon Nol deposed the king in 1970 in a US-supported coup, Nhem En went off to live in the forest with Khmer Rouge leaders and a cadre of child soldiers. He was about ten. Later, when the Khmer Rouge came to power in 1975, he was sent to China with 141 other teens to learn skills for the new regime. That’s where he learned photography.

Nhem En, photographer at S-21 prison, holding a photo of his father, at his home in Siem Reap, Cambodia, 2023

Nhem En shares a photo of his father with the group.

“I came from a very poor family in the countryside. I feel proud to be able to take photographs. For me a photograph is a document, a record,” he explained. We listened transfixed as he answered our questions and proudly showed off his cameras.

Nhem En, photographer at S-21 prison, with his camera, at his home in Siem Reap, Cambodia, 2023

Nhem En came to life when he started to talk about his cameras and his proficiency in photography. He claims his proficiency is what saved his life.

When the conversation got close to what was actually happening at S-21, his flat retelling made it clear that he had to hide his feelings and his fear deep inside the core of his being. He was a photographer who had to pretend that he did not see—or hear—what was right in front of him.

“I had to be careful with everything I did. After seeing people come in with their hands cuffed or other difficult scenes, it became normal,” he said. “The rule was, you do your job; I do my job. Everyone just paid attention to what they did.” He was afraid that one mistake and his life would be over. “If I was careless, my life would be gone and I would not be able to meet all of you today.”

Nahm En, photographer at the Khmer Rouge's S-21 Prison signing a copy of his book, in front of a map of Cambodia at his home in Siem Reap, Cambodia, 2023

After our conversation, Nhem En signed copies of his book, “Nhem En, the Khmer Rouge’s Photographer at S-21.”

Nhem En, who describes himself as a Buddhist, admitted to having feelings for the people he photographed. “I had to save my life first,” he said. “I couldn’t show my feelings or emotion at any moment. What we said was: ‘My hair is on my head and your hair is on your head. I do my job and you do your job.’”

After an hour with Nhem En, we were drained. It’s a year later, and I’m still processing our visit. In the course of learning more, I came across an amazing Academy Award nominated HBO documentary, The Conscience of Nhem En, by producer/director Steven Okazaki of Farallon Films in Berkeley. Steven graciously spent some time on the phone with me, adding his perspective to our observations.

“Nhem En was an unformed kid, an adolescent when he joined the Khmer Rouge. He had to close off his emotions—his anger, his compassion—in order to survive. He has no feelings.” Steven reminded me, “You can’t allow feelings in when you are part of a ritual that ends in death.  If you do, you will break.”

One way Nhem En keeps from breaking is to keep telling his story.

Tuol Sleng Prison Genocide Museum (aka S-21) in Phnom Penh

Just typing those words sent shivers up my spine. These were the places we didn’t want to see in 2005. But by 2023 I was ready to prove to myself that I could look at what history had wrought.

But first, we had half a day to enjoy seeing Phnom Penh. We skipped the tour that included the king’s palace—the same palace where King Norodom Sihanouk was confined under house arrest under the Khmer Rouge. Instead we opted for retail therapy in the French-built grand market in the center of the city. It was one of the best places to see Cambodian people living normal lives two generations after the terror.

Our drive to the former prison with guide Givon Kim showed us a thriving city eager to grow and court investment. Everything felt ordinary until we arrived at the former high school covered in leftover barbed wire.

Barbed wire in front of former school building at Tuol Sleng Prison Genocide Museum (aka S-21), Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2023

The disconnect between the school setting and the prison was startling.

We sat in the courtyard under lovely shade trees as Givon gave us a history lesson in the complexities of Cambodian politics. “In April 1975, when the Khmer Rouge seized the capital, people came out to cheer because they thought the civil war was over. Within two hours, the Khmer Rouge started killing former government workers and evacuating two million people into the countryside,” he said. “They were in power for three years, eight months and twenty days.” It was hard to fathom how quickly history can turn and lives can change.

Guide Givon Kim in the courtyard of Tuol Sleng Prison Genocide Museum (aka S-21), Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2023

Our Phnom Penh guide Givon Kim generously shared his family’s stories from the time of the Khmer Rouge.

At its core, all history is personal. Givon described how his parents fared during that time. “Since my father was a countryside boy, he worked the rice fields. But my mother, 13 at the time, was from town.” Her family was forced from Phnom Penh to work in the fields. She lost her sister, brother and mother to untreated illness. Her grandmother and cousin were arrested and killed. Why? Because her grandmother used a parasol when she went to the fields to work. Like Nhem En said, any mistake could be deadly. Statistically, most families lost from three to ten people.

In the paranoia of the time, the Khmer Rouge leadership saw KGB and CIA spies and enemies everywhere. Hence the need for prisons throughout the country. The four buildings of the former high school and some neighborhood houses were transformed into interrogation and torture centers. Of the 18,000 people who came through S-21, only a dozen people survived. It is estimated that only one percent were guilty of anything.

Angkor Watt guide Choun Siluch in 2005

This billboard behind the Tuol Sleng Prison museum displays a photo of a handful of survivors. It is estimated that 18,000 people went through this prison. Only a dozen survived.

With that, we left the gentle garden to go through the exhibits. Inside we were face to face with hundreds of Nhem En’s photos. The display is overwhelming. Men. Women. Children. Almost all with numbers for identification.

The Vietnamese, who routed the Khmer Rouge in 1979, created this museum just a year later in 1980 to document the brutality of the Khmer Rouge. At first it was a place for the Cambodian people to identify photos of their missing relatives; now it stands as a chilling reminder of what can happen when a fanatically ideological regime takes over.

Building A sign at Tuol Sleng Prison Genocide Museum (aka S-21), Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2023

The message at the Tuol Sleng Prison Museum is clear: Never again.

We went in and out of rooms, once upon a time ordinary school rooms, now exhibits documenting brutality and torture. Instead of the sounds of laughter, a half century ago these rooms were filled with screams of anguish and the stench of fear. Almost everyone who didn’t die here was taken by the truckload to the Choeung Ek Killing Field, once a Chinese cemetery.

Survovor Norng Chan Phal with book at Tuol Sleng Prison Genocide Museum (aka S-21), Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2023

Norng Chan Phal, a child survivor of the Tuol Sleng Prison, hid in the laundry to escape.

On our way out, we met Norng Chan Phal, miraculously one of the orphaned child survivors, holding a book about his life and the Cambodian reconciliation efforts.

Choeung Ek Killing Field

We saw more of Phnom Penh as Givon drove between the two sites. We passed tree-lined French-colonial streets, garment factories, ordinary neighborhoods and new developments, some built with the backing of the Chinese government. Times and alliances evolve. The terror doesn’t last forever.

Exterior pagoda-like gate at Choeung Ek Killing Field Genocidal Center, near Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2003

The entrance gate at the Choeung Ek Genocidal Center.

A pagoda-like gate announced our arrival, and a map marked with audio tour stops with narration in several languages was nearby. The memorial stupa was in the center. It would be our last stop. Since we were with Givon, we skipped the audio tour.

At first glance Choeung Ek looked like what it used to be: a cemetery for burying and remembering family members. A closer look revealed something quite different: a place for killing. It was one of 400 such killing fields in Cambodia in the 1970s.

As we walked through the area that felt like a park, Givon chilled us with the details. The guards lied to the people on the truck, telling them they were bringing them to a place with a new job. “The people were killed at nighttime,” he said. “They used farm implements, not guns, and played loud music so the villagers couldn’t hear the screams.” When they couldn’t kill people quickly enough with knives or farm tools, they used chemicals. The bodies were decapitated because, according to Buddhist belief, if the body is not intact, the soul cannot move on to the next cycle.

Exhibit Executioners' Working Office at Choeung Ek Genocidal Center, near Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2003

Exhibits like this one, the Executioners’ Working Office, dot the grounds of the Choeung Ek killing field. The area was originally a Chinese cemetery.

Signs described the areas. We walked by the truck stop, the executioner’s office, the chemical storage area and the killing tool storage room. I was still struggling to take it all in when we passed the fenced-in mass grave, a vitrine of victim’s old clothes and a collection of bones excavated in 1980. I looked away several times, trying to reconcile the devastating history with the bucolic view across the fields.

Before we reached the memorial stupa, Givon shared some of his own thoughts. “After my generation they don’t believe Cambodians killed Cambodians.” He brought some of his family’s younger generation here so they could learn what happened.

Guide Givon Kim with prayer hands at Choeung Ek Genocidal Center, near Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2003

Our guide, Givon Kim, told us how difficult it is for the younger generations to believe what happened under the Khmer Rouge.

“It’s hard to believe this kind of thing. But it happened,” he told us. “Cambodian history from the first century, we are a good country, an empire. Only in the 20th Century a small group created a bitter history for Cambodia.”

Visitor Ellen Newman offering incence at Choeung Ek Genocidal Center, near Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2003

Before we walked around the memorial stupa with thousands of skulls left by the Khmer Rouge, David and I paid our respects according to Cambodian tradition.

After reaching the center, almost like walking a labyrinth, David and I approached the memorial pagoda, a Buddhist tower that enshrines the bones and skulls of the victims for all to see and remember. As was customary, we took off our shoes, lit incense and placed lotus flowers in the container. Having paid our respects, we walked silently around the stupa memorializing the fallen. We were visitors from afar. But Cambodians come every day, school children to learn what happened and relatives to mourn.

Skulls and bones in memorial stupa at Choeung Ek Genocidal Center, near Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2003

The memorial stupa at Choeung Ek offers a window to a sorrowful time in Cambodian history.

Epilog

It took a year to look back on these experiences in Cambodia. It’s so much more pleasant to remember the magnificent temples, the gracious people and the delicious food. But I had to see and hear these stories for myself.

The sense of a whole country experiencing PTSD that we felt in 2005 had abated. In 2023 we had to ask to hear the stories, but they were readily told. On our first night in Phnom Penh, we could barely get a dinner reservation because Cambodia was celebrating its independence. We were glad to watch the fireworks across the river from a modern skyscraper.

Independence Day fireworks over the river in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, 2003

Celebrating Independence Day in Phnom Penh.

Thanks and credits

Many thanks to Catherine Karnow for curating such an enlightening Vietnam + Cambodia photo workshop. If you are a photographer, Catherine’s workshops are highly recommended.

Thanks also to Steven Okazaki of Berkeley’s Farallon Films for answering a stranger’s email and adding perspective to the enigma of Nhem En. His film The Conscience of Nhem En brings viewers face to face with the Khmer Rouge photographer.

And special thanks to our Cambodian guides, Choun Siluch in 2005 and Givon Kim in 2023, for sharing their family stories with us.

15 Comments

  1. Why do we go to Tuol Sleng and the killing fields, or to famous battlefields like Normandy, or Gettysburg? Is it ghoulish fascination? Or is there a more human impulse at play?

    We speak of “bearing witness,” as if our being there affirms their reality and helps ensure that the world cannot forget. I don’t buy it. We are not witnesses. A witness is someone who was present and can testify to what happened. When General Eisenhower heard about the Nazi death camps, he took his entire general staff to see them firsthand. He knew that history would try to forget, and he wanted to describe what he had seen with his own eyes.

    As modern travelers, we are vicarious viewers of sanitized and curated representations. What’s missing is the event itself – the victims, the sounds and smells. At the killing field, we saw glass cases of recovered clothing and a memorial stupa of respectfully cleaned skulls and bones. We read signs that described mass rapes and the killing of young children. But we didn’t witness any of it.

    But, if we are not witnesses, why are we there? We want to understand humanity’s full range. At the killing fields and concentration camps, we see the depths to which hatred and extremist ideology can move whole societies. At the battlefields, we see the sacrifices that people make for an ideal. We ask the question, “What would I have done?” and hope that the answer is the right one.

    Reply
    • Often, Man’s inhumanity to other men knows no limits! Hope it becomes a rare aberration! But then, Combodia was known as the serene, sleeping beauty!

      Reply
      • Thanks so much for mentioning Cambodia as a “serene, sleeping beauty.” The beauty is still there. We were grateful to be able to enjoy that part of the county as well as touring these historic sites.

        Reply
  2. Very powerful and emotionally written, and complemented by your usual beautiful photography. Another account of men’s incomprehensible in humanity, which is almost forgotten beneath the beauty of Cambodia today.

    Thank you for sharing this.

    Reply
    • Thank you Jim. Visiting Cambodia is another case of “both things are true.” There is both beauty and sorrow as one confronts the killings that went on in the 1970s. What’s hard for me to believe is that all took place 50 years ago!

      Reply
  3. An informative article that left me feeling sombre and thoughtful.
    So many museums and “never again” sites across countries and continents and still it keeps happening; and we feel helpless and hopeless as the madness, the deaths, the destruction goes on.

    We visit these sites which often leaves us feeling shaken by the atrocities they witnessed, and then we move on cynically resigning ourselves to accept the twisted nature of Humankind that creates the twisted world we are all a part of.

    Reply
    • Thank you Ellen, this is an important story to be told, least we forget. Deb

      Reply
      • Thank you Deborah. So many things like this to remember

        Reply
  4. Freni, thank you for writing in from India, another country that experienced its own tragedies in the 1940s. My heart goes out to anyone who has suffered during these historical cataclysms.

    Reply
  5. Carolyn and I were there at the killing fields and S-21. I wrote a post on my blog, but ultimately words fail. We can know the what of such barbarism but the way, to a great degree, remains difficult to fathom. Great piece.

    Reply
    • David, thank you for your thoughts. You are right, words fail. But memory continues to be important.

      Reply
  6. Thank you, Ellen, for this powerful and informative piece on the S-21 torture and killing site in Phnom Penh. Our daughter-in-love, Vaddey Ratner, survived the Khmer Rouge who killed her father, baby sister, and many other family members from 1975-79 (when she was 5-9 years old). She has written a novel on her experience that became a NYT bestseller – In the Shadow of the Banyan. Having her and her family become part of our family has been a great blessing and a source of years of travel to Cambodia, Vietnam, Thailand and Malaysia. The ramifications of the killing fields persist to this day and hopefully will help us stave off similar dictatorships here and elsewhere.

    Reply
    • Joann, thank you for adding the perspective of your family to the story. During my two trips to Cambodia, twenty years apart, I learned that everyone has a story, and that every story touches your heart. I also learned that Cambodia is a beautiful place, well worth visiting.

      Reply
  7. Ellen, this is such a difficult story to write about, but I appreciate you sharing your visit & the stories of those you met.

    Humanity is capable of horrible things..so much damage in under four years! But it’s encouraging to see how a culture can heal and move forward.

    I appreciate David’s questions as well. While we’re not truly “bearing witness”, we are listening to the stories and hopefully, learning. It’s true, we always say “never again” & then it happens somewhere else.

    It’s hard to read about and I can only imagine visiting, but we have to visit, read about and talk about these atrocities—-and see the resilience and beauty that is still in their culture.

    Reply
    • Thank you Tonya. The learning makes such a difference in the ways we see the world. The disregard for human life is so hard to process, but no country and no culture is immune. It makes me sad, but it shifts one’s thinking to see that it can happen pretty much anywhere.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.